A Plant Process Audit is a comprehensive evaluation of the overall performance of the plant’s operations. PEC Consulting systematically evaluates the plant’s operations, identifies the areas that are not working efficiently, and presents its findings and solutions to optimize the plant.
This article was contributed by Narayana (Jay) Jayaraman, Senior Consultant and Technical Services Director of PEC Consulting. He has had in-depth exposure to the technical, economic and commercial aspects of large cement projects, and has extensive experience in the upgrade and optimization of cement plants. He has a MS in Mechanical Engineering from the Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur, India.
Process Audits Steps
1. Benchmarking
Modern, dry-process cement plants with efficient configuration of grinding and pyroprocessing systems typically consume less than 700 kcal/kg-cl thermal energy and 100 kWh/mt of electrical energy. Older plants have inefficient systems, which compounded with operational and maintenance inadequacies, result in much higher energy consumption. Based on the plant’s conditions and specific requirements, general benchmarking is done to set targets. Plant audits evaluate the operation of a cement plant against the appropriate benchmark. After a detailed evaluation, recommendations for plant optimization are made in three levels of capital investment: Step 1: None or very little capital investment — by making adjustments to the operational protocols and improving maintenance Step 2: Minor capital investments – with a payback within 24 months. Step 3: Major capital investments – with a 3- to 5-year payback.2. Historic Evaluation
The plant operational and stoppage data is collected over the past two or more years. The reasons for the stoppages are analyzed in terms of category (mechanical/electrical/instrumentation/refractory/other), duration, and frequency in order to identify causes in order of severity. The plant performance is also analyzed by department. Often a department’s best performance does not occur at the same time of best performance of the plant as a whole. If we choose the best performance times of each department and make them occur at the same time, the plant performance would show a considerably higher level of efficiency. Attempts are made to make them happen at the same time, which is not an unrealistic target as the departments had indeed performed at that level in the past Through a systematic approach, all departments are made to perform at the highest possible level thus increasing the plant’s overall productivity.3. Thermal Energy
Thermal energy relates to the Pyroprocessing system. For a 1 million mt/year clinker production, savings of 10 kcal/kg-cl would result in annual savings of approximately $185,000. (1,000,000 tpy*1,000 kg/y*10 kcal/yr * $120/t-coal (6,500kcal/kg-coal/1,000 t coal) Another significant advantage in most cases is that the reduction in heat consumption can be utilized to increase production. Potential savings can also be derived from:- Cooler optimization
- Arresting in-leakages
- Optimization of operational strategy
4. Electrical Energy
Large fans and mill drives are major consumers of electrical energy. Fans — fan power is linked to specific heat consumption and many operational parameters. Optimization of these parameters will help lowering fan power consumption. Mills – in the case of ball mills, optimization of the mill charge and upkeep of the mill internals will minimize power consumption. As for vertical roller mills, the inspection of mill internals and separator and adjustments in the operation will bring about improvements, both in energy consumption and production increase.5. Chemistry and Operations Strategy
Clinker quality related issues are addressed by evaluating the chemistry and operational parameters.6. Emissions Management
The inadequacy of emission management systems generally found in older plants does not meet current emission regulations. PEC Consulting can analyze emission levels and provide solutions to improve emission management. The expert staff at PEC Consulting Group has the capability to undertake Plant Process Audits and provide ongoing technical assistance to cement plants to improve operational performance. The scope of work generally includes:- Plant visit and discussions with the plant’s operating personnel
- Data collection of historical stoppages and operating parameters
- Analysis of the data to identify areas for improvement
- Submission of a report providing observations and recommendations, including economic analysis to establish the cost/benefit ratios.
- Develop an implementation program with the Plant Management
- Work with Operating personnel through periodic goal-setting and audits until the prescribed performance goals are achieved.
This article was contributed by Narayana (Jay) Jayaraman, Senior Consultant and Technical Services Director of PEC Consulting. He has had in-depth exposure to the technical, economic and commercial aspects of large cement projects, and has extensive experience in the upgrade and optimization of cement plants. He has a MS in Mechanical Engineering from the Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur, India.
