Waste Heat Recovery for Power Generation

Hot process gases that are vented to the atmosphere by a Process Plant represent a potential for the generation of electric power. The installation of a Waste Heat Recovery (WHR) System is a “green” option that must be considered.


The Waste Heat Recovery (WHR) System consists of a steam generation unit and a power generation unit. The steam generation unit is a set of boilers placed in the path of the waste gases. The heat in the gases, sometimes supplemented by additional heat in the co- generation process, is used for generating steam. The steam can be used for other process requirements within the industrial plant, or used for driving a turbine that is connected to the generator. The generated power can either be used for running plant equipment or fed back to the power grid.

The recovered waste heat represents “green energy” since it is a direct savings in the use of fossil fuels with the consequent reduction of carbon dioxide emissions. Furthermore, cooling of the process gases is done without wasting scarce water or diluting with ambient air that would increase the energy consumption of the fans.

Several challenges exist, such as sticky and abrasive dust in the gas, or corrosive vapors such as SO2. The boiler must be custom-designed carefully to handle the specific characteristics of the off-gases. In special cases, like when there is a low gas temperature, an Organic Rankine cycle can be chosen instead of the steam cycle. The recovered waste heat represents “green energy” since it is a direct savings in the use of fossil fuels with the consequent reduction of carbon dioxide emissions. Furthermore, cooling of the process gases is done without wasting scarce water or diluting with ambient air that would increase the energy consumption of the fans.


PEC Consulting’s feasibility studies evaluate the characteristics of the process plant’s off-gases and assess the quantity of heat that can be usefully recovered. PEC Consulting will evaluate space limitations and find a solution to place the boilers and power generation system and integrate new equipment with the existing. PEC Consulting’s feasibility studies provide the client with an assessment of the power potential, a financial analysis with capital and operating cost estimates, and a layout to integrate the Waste Heat Recovery System with the existing process plant.

Waste Heat Recovery (WHR) Systems help process industries to become part of the green revolution by conserving natural resources. In addition to providing a reliable electrical supply, the reduction of the carbon footprint helps the environment. A co-generation plant is also a great benefit when the power grid supplying the plant is unreliable or when the plant is subject to interruptible power.

PEC Consulting can help the process industries with the realization of this noble and profitable goal.


View additional feature articles under PublicationsContact Us

Developing Frac Sand Quarries

Silica sand is one of the most abundant minerals on the Earth’s crust. However, not any sand will work for gas and oil extraction. The industry is looking for specific gradations of sand between 1.2mm and 0.2mm. This sand should be clean, well rounded and have a Mohs hardness near 7.

Hydraulic fracturing is a key method of extracting unconventional oil and gas resources. As a rule, formations of shale gas resources have lower permeability than conventional gas formations and therefore, depending on the geological characteristics of the formation, specific technologies, such as hydraulic fracturing, are required. Although there are also other methods to extract these resources, such as conventional drilling or horizontal drilling, hydraulic fracturing is one of the key methods making their extraction technically viable. The multi-stage fracturing technique has facilitated shale gas and light tight oil production development in the United States and is believed to do so in the other countries with unconventional hydrocarbon resources. Significance of the extraction of unconventional hydrocarbons lies also in the fact that these resources are less concentrated than of conventional oil and gas resources.

The technique of hydraulic fracturing is used to increase or restore the rate at which fluids, such as natural gas, can be produced from subterranean natural reservoirs. Reservoirs are typically porous sandstones, limestones, or dolomite rocks, but also include “unconventional reservoirs” such as shale rock and coal beds. Hydraulic fracturing enables the production of natural gas and oil from rock formation deep below the earth’s surface (generally, 5,000 – 20,000 feet). At such depth, there may not be sufficient permeability or reservoir pressure to allow natural gas and oil to flow from the rock into the wellbore at economic rates. Thus, creating conductive fracture in the rock is pivotal to extract gas from shale reservoirs because of the extremely low natural permeability of shale. Fractures provide a conductive path connecting a larger volume of the reservoir to the well. So-called “super fracking”, which creates cracks deeper in the rock formation to release more oil and gas, will allow companies to frack more efficiently.

Source: Hydraulic fracturing – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.


Figure 1: Frac Sand Quarry, after blast

Figure 1 shows a sandstone deposit in mid-Texas, typical of high-quality raw materials. The deposit has approximately 30 meters of overburden. The sandstone is mined, crushed and pre-graded, washed in attrition mills to further liberate the unwanted particle size both hydraulically and with vibrating screens.

The process may yield only 25% usable sand. The wet processing includes the removal of the clays and fine silica. After wet processing, the sand is dried, mechanically screened and separated into specific gradations appropriate for fracing.

Water is needed to liberate the fines. On-site water recovery, water management, clarifier and retention ponds are required. Mine permits, quarry plans, core analysis, logistics for the operations are necessary. Air quality, highway access, and use permits are all part of project development.

The frac sand user, the petroleum well driller, needs about 3,000 tons per well of sand. The driller mixes sand with other ingredients and water and injects the slurry into the well at about 50,000 psi pressure. A continuous high quality source of sand is imperative to obtain the maximum yield from the gas/oil bearing shale.

After the sand has been dried and screened, various 4 gradations of frac sand will be ready for transport to the drill site. The operation runs 24 hours per day, 7 days per week and may provide millions of tons of sand per year to customers. Logistically, this means that hundreds of pneumatic tankers of sand will be loaded, sampled, tested and released to customers each day.

To the quarry, it means that for every 5 million tons of sandstone processed each year, the mine operator must handle 3 million tons of sand tailings with reclaiming and revegetation plans.

PEC Consulting helps owners benefit from thorough planning. Our consultants have years of experience designing and operating quarries and logistics systems. We have qualified miners, engineers, materials handling experts, layout professionals and planners. Have us conceptualize and develop your deposit in this fast-growing field.



Main feature contributor: Thomas W. Hedrick, P.E.

View additional feature articles under PublicationsContact Us





Cement Industry – Plant Process Audits

Contact Us » icon-contact2x

A Plant Process Audit is a comprehensive evaluation of the overall performance of the plant’s operations. PEC Consulting systematically evaluates the plant’s operations, identifies the areas that are not working efficiently, and presents its findings and solutions to optimize the plant.


Steps for Process Audits

  1. Benchmarking

    Modern, dry-process cement plants with efficient configuration of grinding and pyro processing systems typically consume less than 700 kcal/kg-cl thermal energy and 100 kWh/mt of electrical energy. Older plants have inefficient systems, which compounded with operational and maintenance inadequacies, tend to have much higher energy consumption. Based on the plant’s conditions and specific requirements, general benchmarking is done to set targets. Plant audits evaluate the operation of a cement plant against the appropriate benchmark. After a detailed evaluation, recommendations for plant optimization are made in three levels of capital investment:

    Step 1: None or very little capital investment — by making adjustments to the operational protocols and improving maintenance
    Step 2: Minor capital investments – with payback within 24 months.
    Step 3: Major capital investments – with 3- to 5-year payback.

  2. Historic Evaluation

    The plant operational and stoppage data is collected over the past two or more years. The reasons for the stoppages are analyzed in terms of category (mechanical/electrical/instrumentation/refractory/other), duration, and frequency in order to identify causes in order of severity.

    The plant performance is also analyzed by department. Often a department’s best performance does not occur at the same time of the best performance of the plant as a whole. If we choose the best performance times of each department and make them occur at the same time, the plant performance would show a considerably higher level of efficiency. Attempts are made to make them happen at the same time, which is not an unrealistic target as the departments had indeed performed at that level in the past.

    Through a systematic approach, all departments are made to perform at the highest possible level thus increasing the plant’s overall productivity.

  3. Thermal Energy

    Thermal energy relates to the Pyroprocessing system. For a 1 million mt/year clinker production, savings of 10 kcal/kg-cl would result in annual savings of approximately $185,000.

    (1,000,000 tpy*1,000 kg/y*10 kcal/yr * $120/t-coal
    (6,500kcal/kg-coal/1,000 t coal)

    Another significant advantage in most cases is that the reduction in heat consumption can be utilized to increase production.

    Potential savings can also be derived from:

    • Cooler optimization
    • Arresting in-leakages
    • Optimization of operational strategy
  4. Electrical Energy

    Large fans and mill drives are major consumers of electrical energy.

    Fans — fan power is linked to specific heat consumption and many operational parameters. Optimization of these parameters will help lowering fan power consumption.

    Mills – in the case of ball mills, optimization of the mill charge and upkeep of the mill internals will minimize power consumption. As for vertical roller mills, the inspection of mill internals and separator, and adjustments in the operation will bring about improvements, both in energy consumption and production increase.

  5. Chemistry and Operations Strategy

    Clinker quality related issues are addressed by evaluating the chemistry and operational parameters.

  6. Emissions management

    The inadequacy of emission management systems generally found in older plants do not meet current emission regulations. PEC Consulting can analyze emission levels and provide solutions to improve emission management.

PEC Consulting Group’s Active Participation in the Industry

PEC Consulting Group has experienced staff to undertake Plant Process Audits and provide ongoing technical assistance to cement plants to improve operational performance. The scope of work generally includes:

  • Plant visit and discussions with the plant’s operating personnel
  • Data collection of historical stoppages and operating parameters
  • Analysis of the data to identify areas for improvement
  • Submission of a report providing observations and recommendations, including economic analysis to establish the cost/benefit ratios.
  • Develop with the Plant Management an implementation program.
  • Work with Operating personnel through periodic goal-setting and audits until the prescribed performance goals are achieved.

A Plant Audit is the foundation to optimize the plant operations and often presents the lowest cost/benefit investment ratio.

Please contact for specific applications where we could be of service.

View additional feature articles under PublicationsContact Us





Feasibility Studies

PENTA Engineering Corp. (PENTA) has been in business since 1986. Throughout its history, PENTA has undertaken consulting assignments, such as conceptual studies, pre-feasibility studies, feasibility studies, plant audits, and operations training. These assignments are now the full focus of the PENTA subsidiary, PEC CONSULTING GROUP LLC.

Consulting assignments call for the participation of highly-experienced staff. Usually, front-end scoping work is sophisticated professional work used as a basis for important business decisions requiring the participation of high level consultants. Studies undertaken go beyond technical matters, including the economic analysis, taking into account sales projections, logistics, estimates of capital investments and operating costs. Parties interested in these comprehensive studies are the owners, investors and financing organizations.


At the early stages of a Greenfield project, a Conceptual Study is done to analyze the possibilities and benefits of a potential project. This is an economical way for management to do a Preliminary Evaluation of a potential project. The next step, a Pre-feasibility study, is usually carried out ahead of a Feasibility Study to provide an economic assessment of a project which has already been determined to have a high potential of development. Basic Engineering is then developed to set up the project. Changes to the project concept occur during this phase which lasts until equipment is procured.

Some customers are focused only in the technical aspects of a feasibility study, such as the process analysis and enough engineering for the capital cost estimating. However, a more comprehensive study that includes the evaluation of minerals reserves, the potential market, and the economics of the project is required for appropriate decision making. For example, owners may use this type of study to determine the value of one potential investment versus others. The financing entities and investors need to assure themselves that the project will generate the cash flows necessary for the project owner to pay down the debt.

All the above is to say that the consulting arm of PENTA has the purpose of utilizing the technical talents from our engineering divisions and extending the service to further offer customers a more comprehensive package.

The following is a typical Table of Contents of a Feasibility Study (Click to view larger):

feature-article-feasibility-studies-table-of-contentsPlease contact for specific applications where we could be of service.

View additional feature articles under PublicationsContact Us






Industrial Minerals

PEC Consulting Group LLC, the consulting arm of PENTA Engineering Corp., is recognized worldwide for providing engineering and consulting services to the industrial minerals industry. Our extensive experience comprises limestone, cement, lime, gypsum, sands, aggregates and other non-metallic minerals.


PEC Consulting Group has the capacity to develop complete projects from concept to commissioning for Greenfield Plants Projects and Plant expansions. Our services cover:

  • Scoping Studies.
  • Conceptual and Economic Study, including plant and mine design.
  • Project Schedule Development, CAPEX Studies and OPEX Studies.
  • Economic Studies, Market Studies and Financial Studies.
  • Pre Feasibility and Bankable Feasibility Studies for new plants and plant expansions.
  • Investigation and evaluation of raw materials.
  • Sampling and evaluation of mineral deposits.
  • Geological studies Mine and quarry planning.
  • Environmental emissions assessment and selection of control technologies for particulate matter.
  • Operations improvement.
  • Flow diagram development.
  • Selection of process equipment and evaluation of existing equipment.
  • Due Diligence for Acquisitions.
  • Mergers and Acquisitions.
  • Process Audits and productivity improvements.
  • Maintenance and Reliability Audits.
  • Operations evaluation and operators training.
  • Development of Bid Documents for Main Process Equipment.
  • Contract Negotiation.
  • Closure of Contracts.
  • Auxiliary Equipment Selection Assistance and Material handling.
  • Contractor Selection Assistance.
  • Quality Assurance / Quality Control Monitoring.
  • Procurement & Expediting Assistance.
  • Site Advisory Services.
  • Commissioning and Start-up Assistance.

Industrial Minerals Consultants

PENTA has been providing consulting services to the industrial minerals industry for over 28 years. Our consultants have extensive experience in the following Industries:

  • Cement.
  • Clays.
  • Diatomaceous Earths.
  • Feldspar.
  • Frac Sands (Proppant Sands).
  • Ground Calcium Carbonate.
  • Gypsum.
  • Industrial Sands.
  • Kaolin.
  • Lime.
  • Limestone and Dolomite.
  • Perlite.
  • Precipitated Calcium Carbonate.
  • Pozzolans.
  • Refractory Clays.
  • Salts.
  • Silica Sands.
  • Wollastonite.

Clients List

  • US Silica.
  • Pioneer Natural Resources.
  • Cutler Magner.
  • Florida Crushed Stone.
  • Florida Rock Industries.
  • Salt River Materials Group
  • United States Lime & Minerals, Inc.
  • …among others

Contact Us

PEC Consulting is experienced in all aspects of cement distribution.

airview 1Areas of expertise for cement import terminals include comprehensive studies for cost-effective solutions for the distribution of cement to a satellite market. Our knowledgeable staff has performed many studies for the development of cement distribution terminals to fit our clients’ requirements. One of them, the cement transfer terminal with modular rail unloader, automated truck load-out and weight scale system, minimizes construction costs and installation time. Other designs, like the one appropriate for navigable rivers uses river cells for proper draft for the ship or barge.

airview w bargeWe perform studies for cement distribution systems with logistics costs in mind. Regardless of the design, all the components of the cement terminal, including the storage facility and conveying system, will be laid out to obtain optimal logistics and efficient ship loading. Consideration is also provided for the environment —  a dust collector and a simple and complete de-dusting circuit is included in the design.  Our services include:

  • Feasibility and Technical Studies for Distribution Networks
  • Investigation of potential rail, river, or ocean transportation systems
  • Logistical analysis of industrial distribution
  • Technology comparison of equipment tenders
  • Conceptual through detailed design of the cement terminal and equipment
  • Capital cost and operating cost estimates
  • Logistical cost studies and overall project economics of alternatives

Learn more about Cement Distribution Logistics – click on the following publications:Port of Cleveland Ohio cement silos

Contact Us

Feasibility Studies

We believe that the experience with our own successful company makes us an excellent consultancy to create an effective plan prepared to serve your particular needs. An independent analysis of your project economics and a strong business plan will not only help you locate the funds you need, but will also clarify your own purpose and serve as a guide for future growth and productivity.

PEC Consulting creates the kind of economic models that banks want as support for financing. Our Feasibility reports provide professional financial projections and address the needs of investors and lenders.

We take into consideration the technical and financial phases of a project for the preparation of a Feasibility Study. An estimate is made of all equipment, systems and energy requirements, a financial analysis is then prepared, including operating and capital costs. A Feasibility Study also gives detailed site logistics and transport requirements.

Our services are interrelated. We see the benefit to our clients when we are awarded the preparation of a conceptual study or a pre-feasibility study prior to that of a Feasibility Study. This preliminary work will be most valuable to determine whether to proceed with project evaluation.

Furthermore, and along the same line of a Feasibility Study, we are qualified to assist our clients from financial organizations with pre-credit feasibility studies, which provide an independent and thorough analysis and verification of the data submitted to our clients by their customers. PEC CONSULTING has performed Conceptual Feasibility Studies, Feasibility Studies, Pre-Feasibility Studies, and Pre-Credit Feasibility Studies, including capital cost estimates in many countries around the world, including recent projects in the United States, Trinidad, Colombia, Peru, Paraguay, Africa, and Kuwait.

We have the expertise to produce the following studies:

Contact Us

The use of Alternative Fuels, also known as “Co-Processing”, is the use of combustible waste materials as a source of energy in pyro-processing of cement manufacturing plants, lime plants, and in the calcining of other minerals.

Some forms of alternative fuels are:

  • Used tires
  • Plastic waste (bags, bottles etc.)
  • Waste Oils
  • Solvents
  • Saw dust
  • Paint
  • Hazardous Wastes
  • RDF (Refuse Derived Fuels)


Conversion to Alternative Fuels benefits the economy of operation by lowering fuel costs. In some cases, a facility that uses Alternative Fuels receives economic compensation for waste elimination (e.g. use of Hazardous Wastes). In addition to energy recovery, there are considerable environmental/green benefits, such as the reduction of emissions and greenhouse gases into the atmosphere by not using natural non-renewable raw materials and fuels such as coal. In certain countries, these savings can be utilized for Carbon Trading credits.

However, because of their inherent characteristics, the implementation of Alternative Fuels present a challenge to use which, if not handled properly, may impact the manufacturing process, product quality, and environmental exposure.

What We Do

At PEC Consulting we provide innovative and thoughtful solutions to help the cement industry and lime industry implement co-processing at their plants and become more cost efficient, which improves their economic competitiveness.

An Alternative Fuels Project will evaluate the characteristics of co-processing and recommend ways to handle and utilize fuels in the pyro-process in the most effective and secure way.

Our scope of work includes:

  • Studies for handling and firing Solid Waste Fuels
  • Studies for handling and firing Liquid Waste Fuels
  • Studies for handling and firing Hazardous Waste Fuels
  • Conceptual studies to use whole or shredded tires
  • Studies to use gas or petroleum coke (petcoke) as replacement fuel
  • Alternative Fuels / Co-Processing Studies for Cement Plants
  • Alternative Fuels / Co-Processing Studies for Lime Plants

Contact Us

Waste Heat Recovery Systems (WHR) utilize the heat in industrial waste gases for the generation of electrical power. WHR Systems are common in cement and lime plants and other pyroprocess industries where Rotary Kilns are used and the price and reliability of grid power supply make the investment economically feasible.

In developing the concepts for the WHR system, the challenge lies in determining the optimum quantity of waste heat available for power generation and in integrating the WHR system with the cement process. PEC Consulting can assist the client to perform a Feasibility Study to assess the optimum size and configuration of the WHR system and the viability of the project. The study will provide recommendations for an efficient and economical system based on several factors such as the thermal capacity of exhaust gases, size and type of heat exchanger, and desired parameters of the cogeneration system operating conditions.

In some cogeneration systems, the exhaust gas from power generator sets using diesel oil or furnace oil is used as a source of heat for the WHR plant.


  • Reduction of electrical power demand from the grid and consequently of the plant’s operating costs.
  • Reliable electrical power supply from waste gases from the kiln and cooler.
  • Reduction of the carbon footprint by conserving the use of fossil fuels and thus helping the environment.

What We Do

  • Assess the realistic quantity of heat that can be recovered taking into account variations in the drying requirements of raw materials and fuel throughout the year. This analysis results in optimum sizing of the WHR system.
  • Determine the energy recovery process to be utilized: The steam Rankine cycle uses water as the thermodynamic medium and is commonly used for generating power from high temperature sources. Depending on the temperature and other situational factors, some plants use the Organic Rankine cycle for generating power, using an organic compound as the thermodynamic medium.
  • Optimize the layout of the boilers and power generation system considering plant footprint space constraints.
  • Provide an effective integration of the WHR equipment with the existing cement plant or industrial facility.
  • • Provide our clients with an assessment of the power potential, a financial analysis with capital and operating cost estimates, and an economic analysis to assess the viability of the project.
  • Technical Feasibility Studies of WHR Systems for Cement Plants.
  • Technical Feasibility Studies of WHR Systems for Lime Plants.

Learn more about WHR; click on the following publication:

Waste Heat Recovery for Power Generation

To download a list or Energy Efficiency/Process Studies, including WHR projects, please click here

Contact Us

PEC Consulting offers extensive experience to your metallurgical processes and operations. Our team consists of industrial metallurgical experts who are highly qualified and capable to investigate and find solutions to improve your existing operations. We will provide an independent assessment of our findings and recommendations in a thorough and clear report.

We have considerable knowledge in extractive metallurgy. Our workforce has many years experience in the physical and chemical processes for the separation and concentration of raw materials and have provided engineering to cover all aspects of this operation from crushing and grinding the ore to concentrating, smelting, casting, and refining processes.

We have demonstrated leadership when providing material characterization studies for the extraction of metal ores. Minerals deposits are analyzed using state-of-the art microscopy technologies and computer software to identify and determine ore deposits for metals manufacturing.

We have been active participants in projects that involved areas of hydro-metallurgical and pyro-metallurgical treatment of various types of ores for the beneficiation and recovery of copper, gold, silver, platinum, zinc, lead manganese, uranium, vanadium, zirconium, molybdenum, nickel and the rare earths.

Our experts in the field of lead processing have in-depth knowledge in lead production, smelting of lead materials, refining, and material design. Our services have been provided with an understanding of the environmental impact when establishing processing parameters. We have participated in environmental improvement projects, major plant expansions and modifications, including smelters, ductwork, barge unloading facilities and truck loading stations.

Contact Us